Heart rate zones: % of max vs Karvonen vs LTHR
Three ways to set heart rate zones (percent of max, Karvonen heart rate reserve and Friel's LTHR zones), worked through for one runner, and when to use each.
Heart rate zones are the most common way to put a number on "easy", "steady" and "hard". The catch is that there are several ways to draw them, and they disagree, sometimes by a whole zone. This guide works one runner through the three systems you'll meet most (percent of max, heart rate reserve, and threshold heart rate), then covers which to use when.
The runner
Our example runner is 50, with a measured max heart rate of 185, a resting heart rate of 50, and a threshold heart rate (LTHR) of 170 from a 30-minute test. All the tables below come from the same zone calculator Fit File Forge's coach uses, with five zones each.
1. Percent of max heart rate
The simplest system: each zone is a slice of your maximum. With edges at 60, 70, 80 and 90% of max (the common five-zone split, and the default on many Garmin watches):
| Zone | Name | Range |
|---|---|---|
| Z1 | Recovery | ≤ 110 bpm |
| Z2 | Aerobic | 111–129 bpm |
| Z3 | Tempo | 130–147 bpm |
| Z4 | Threshold | 148–166 bpm |
| Z5 | VO₂max | ≥ 167 bpm |
It's easy, but it has two problems. First, it needs a real max. The age formulas are averages: 220 minus age says 170 for our runner, and Tanaka's better-fitting 208 − 0.7 × age says 173, both well under the 185 he has actually seen. Individuals routinely sit 10 or more beats away from either formula, which shifts every zone. Second, percent of max ignores where you start: two runners with the same max and very different resting heart rates get identical zones.
If you use it, use a max you've seen in a hard race or an all-out hill effort, not a formula. (When Fit File Forge estimates max heart rate from your activities, it takes the second-highest per-session max across at least five sessions, so one strap glitch can't set it; the age formula is only a last resort.)
2. Heart rate reserve (Karvonen)
Martti Karvonen's 1957 study of training intensity introduced the idea of working from the reserve: the beats between resting and max. Each zone edge is resting heart rate plus a share of that reserve:
target = resting + share × (max − resting)
For our runner the reserve is 185 − 50 = 135 beats, and with the same 60/70/80/90% edges:
| Zone | Name | Range |
|---|---|---|
| Z1 | Recovery | ≤ 130 bpm |
| Z2 | Aerobic | 131–144 bpm |
| Z3 | Tempo | 145–157 bpm |
| Z4 | Threshold | 158–171 bpm |
| Z5 | VO₂max | ≥ 172 bpm |
Every zone sits higher than in the percent-of-max version, especially the low ones: Zone 2 now starts at 131 instead of 111. Fitter athletes, with low resting heart rates and a big reserve, usually find Karvonen's easy zones closer to how easy actually feels.
To use it you need a fair resting heart rate. Measure it yourself: sit or lie quietly for a few minutes on a calm day and take the lowest steady reading, on more than one day.
3. Threshold heart rate (Friel)
Joe Friel anchors zones to your lactate threshold heart rate instead of max. Find LTHR with a 30-minute solo time trial (your average heart rate for the last 20 minutes; the threshold pace guide has the details), then set zones as percentages of it. Friel's running zones:
| Zone | Name | Range |
|---|---|---|
| Z1 | Recovery | ≤ 144 bpm |
| Z2 | Aerobic | 145–152 bpm |
| Z3 | Tempo | 153–161 bpm |
| Z4 | Threshold | 162–169 bpm |
| Z5 | Above threshold | ≥ 170 bpm |
Friel's cycling zones use slightly different edges (81, 90 and 94% of LTHR for the lower three), and your cycling LTHR is usually a few beats lower than your running one, so test each sport separately. Friel splits his top zone into 5a, 5b and 5c; Fit File Forge keeps it as one "above threshold" zone, because everything above LTHR behaves alike in a heart rate trace.
Same run, three answers
Now the useful part. Say our runner does an easy run at a steady 140 bpm:
- Percent of max: Zone 3, "tempo". He'd think he's running too hard.
- Karvonen: Zone 2, "aerobic". Easy.
- Friel LTHR: Zone 1, "recovery". Very easy.
A threshold session at 165 bpm reads as Zone 4 in all three, but it sits at the very top of Zone 4 by percent of max and in the middle of it for the other two. Same heart, same run, different words. None of them is wrong; they're different rulers. What matters is that you pick one, set it from real numbers, and keep the workouts written in the same ruler.
Which to use when
- You know your LTHR: use Friel's zones. They're anchored to the intensity that matters most for endurance training, and they line up with threshold pace and FTP zones. This is the system Fit File Forge prefers when you've entered an LTHR.
- You know your max and resting heart rate, but not LTHR: use Karvonen. Fit File Forge falls back to it when both are set.
- You only know your max: percent of max is fine, especially for easy running. It's also what interval studies often prescribe. The Norwegian 4 × 4 protocol (Helgerud and colleagues, 2007) is written as 4 minutes at 90–95% of max heart rate, which is why the library's version keeps that as a percent your watch works out from its own max.
- You know none of them: run a 30-minute test or race before you trust any zone. An age formula is a starting guess, not a setting.
Where heart rate falls short
Heart rate lags effort by a minute or more, so it's a poor target for short intervals: a 2-minute rep will be nearly over before your heart rate gets there. Use pace or power for reps under a few minutes, and heart rate for steady running and for capping easy days. Heart rate also drifts upward over a long run, and runs higher in heat. A run that creeps from Zone 2 into Zone 3 in its last half hour at the same pace is normal, not a failure.
Putting zones on your watch
Most Garmin watches let you set heart rate zones from max, heart rate reserve or LTHR in their own settings, and a structured workout with a heart rate target uses those zones. When a library workout says "90–95% of max heart rate", your watch fills in the beats from the max in its own settings, so keep that number current. Work your own zones out with the training zones calculator, or try a session set by heart rate:
Send these to your watch
Sources
- M. J. Karvonen, E. Kentala, O. Mustala. The effects of training on heart rate: a longitudinal study. Annales Medicinae Experimentalis et Biologiae Fenniae 35(3): 307–315, 1957.
- Hirofumi Tanaka, Kevin D. Monahan, Douglas R. Seals. Age-predicted maximal heart rate revisited. Journal of the American College of Cardiology 37(1): 153–156, 2001.
- Joe Friel. Joe Friel's Quick Guide to Setting Zones. TrainingPeaks.
- Jan Helgerud et al.. Aerobic high-intensity intervals improve VO2max more than moderate training. Medicine & Science in Sports & Exercise 39(4): 665–671, 2007.
Written by Caleb Wetherell; drafted with AI assistance and checked against the sources below.
Training information, not medical advice.
Want this at your paces, on your watch?
Describe it in plain words: your coach builds it at your numbers, ready to send to your Garmin.
Your coach drafts your first week free, from your Garmin training. No card.